I am a secular being, I believe in what’s right is right , what’s wrong is wrong , what’s ethical and what’s not but more importantly in the equality of all human being irrespective of caste, creed, religion or ethnicity. And like you and many others (according to the media, the whole nation), I was shaken by the hate speech saga propounded by Varun Gandhi. Their seems to be a lot of fuzz around Varun Gandhi’s treacherous comments.( these are the adjectives given by the media world to it).But there is a difference, I am not annoyed with what Varun Gandhi for making such statements but I disapprove of what followed suit.
The congress, media, election commission or anybody else for that matter, can blame Varun Gandhi to be a communal hardcore proponent of hindutva. I couldn’t approve more that the comments were communal and not secular. But, is he the only communist in our country? Is he the only one with non-secular track record among those participating in the elections? The answer is NO!! news channels have pointed the names like Jagdish Tytler( the controversial name relating to communal violence of 1983 riots in Delhi), Sanjay Dutt( a big Bollywood star found guilty under the arms act and have served 18 months in jail) and Shibu Soren (who was believed to be involved in the infamous 1994 sashi nath murder case) and we know that there are more. It’s rather ironic that all these communal criminals are contesting elections for the secular congress party.
The Indian national congress (as we already know) is the oldest and the most decorated national party in India. It has produced leaders from Jawahar Lal Nehru to Rahul Gandhi all proud of their secular principles. They certainly seem proud if we go by what priyanka Gandhi spoke in the media. She advised Varun Gandhi to read Geeta and better understand the meaning of hindutva. Well, it seems that we all need a Geeta updesh from an indo-Italian half hindu. (It’s a shame).
My head is buzzing off late because of this great Indian political tamasha. Election time is serious politics time in my country (after all, we are the world’s biggest democracy). I might not approve of a lot of things in our political system but am sure proud of the size and vastness of Indian politics (Our country must be producing the best political researchers in the entire world). For managing such a big election event, we need a competent authority to manage it. So, we have the election commission, a major player in the whole story. The election commission has come strongly against Varun Gandhi denying him any right to prove his case of video tampering and editing. They went a step further when EC chief Navin chawla advised BJP to ban Varun Gandhi from contesting the elections in their name and also reprimanding him to be used in the election campaign. The EC have also found the Gandhi in question guilty of violating the code of conduct.
I think any voter of our country who knows about politics a little is aware of the incompetence and biasness of the Election Commission of India. I would site a story dated 31st January, 2009 (http://www.merinews.com/catFull.jsp?articleID=15709356) in which N Gopalaswami (the chief election commissioner) has recommended issuing a pink slip to Election commissioner Navin chawla following the complaints from BJP regarding his partisan functioning at the office. The election commissioners of India have surely lost its credibility and time and time again have proved their affiliation towards different political parties (Who is guilty now of violation of code of conduct?)
If you have followed the whole “hate speech story” in the media or even if you haven’t, you would agree that the people most affected by it are the Bhartiya Janta Party. BJP came out in full force to deny any link of theirs with Varun Gandhi’s hate speech. BJP spokes person Ravi Shankar Prasad spoke to the media distancing BJP from Varun Gandhi’s statements.
The BJP’s reaction to the whole issue has not surprised me. The party think tank is worried that their association with Varun Gandhi will dilute the party’s image and will weaken their stand in the forthcoming elections. It is understandable as the party is trying to project a secular image for some time now. L K Advani’s visit to Pakistan and calling Mohamad ali Jinah secular or BJP’s rift with RSS and VHP have made it very obvious to the voters of the BJP’s new secular avatar.
The BJP’s ideological confusion is a result of their improper identification of their target market (the vote bank). The party has always been a hardcore hindutva party marketing itself to the Hindu middle class. The “JAI SHRI RAM” has lost its shine in the recent years and the party is now caught right in the middle of nowhere (no proper leadership or ideology – only Ram can save them).
Varun Gandhi’s speech has been certainly hyped out of proportion. In politics, the politician has to take a stand and define what he believes in and what he rejects. The Gandhi being talked about here has adopted an ideology and has explained the nation his principles and ideas. The media, nation or the political clout can call him communal, fundamentalist or so on and so forth. But sadly, he is the only politician of all available on display who has no ideological confusions like BJP, no double standards of congress, knows his lessons of Geeta and who cares about EC anyways.
3 comments:
Kudos ! indeed a thought provoking blog .
The word "secular " has been reiterated so many times by every Tom , Dick and Harriet in the whole Varun episode that its meaning seems lost in confusion. Secular to me means freedom of religion and freedom from of religion. So, when it is said that India is a secular state it means that every indiviual has a right to follow his religion but as a country (government), it should be impartial towards any religion.
Now coming to Varun Gandhi and his tirade.i dont really see nething wrong with it .Infact, it falls under the purview of secularim . If atrocities are committed against any religion ( hinduism or any other), the wrong doer must be punished.Isn't that wat a secular state stands for?
What went wrong for Varun in this fiasco is , that he wanted to emerge as the junior Narender Modi with his high voltage exceptionally good oratory skills but fell flat on his face. Welcome to Indian politics Mr Varun Gandhi !!
Warm wellcome to the blogers arena!
And you deserve more than a round of applause for what you have expressed here...
But then, this is not how things can be carried on.
We on the blogging community represent hardly 3.75 per cent of the Indian population as per the internet penetration figures provided by NASSCOM. That means there is a whole India who doesn't have a platform to espress his or her views like a blog and it also means that that particular chunk of population is devoid of any of our inputs through this platform.
As well of note is the fact that in spite of best efforts, India still has 30 % of its population illiterate, devoid of print media that means absolutely in the dark.
When one is not educated, it is a safe assumption to make,that he is not in a best possible situation to make rational judgements, that leads us to a conclusion that he makes emotional choices.
Speech or oration has a potential of arousing people. Hitler, Churchill, Vajpayee, Nehru, Sardar Patel, Narendra Modi are all great orators in their own right and hence in part good leaders.
Now, if such inflammatory speeches arouses any kind of communal hatred among the people at large, it leads to anarchy and arson in the country and hence, he should be censored.
Indian electorate and the governing bodies hence need to take action against Rahul Gandhi, and I feel, have done justifiably so.
Bingo...!!
Rightly said even I agree that what followed the suit after the comments made by the Varun Gandhi were more of media biased. One issue that needs should have been addressed is the place-Pilibhit where Varun's comments came has always been under communal tensions. There have been instances when the muslim community have attacked hindu carrying on their procession on occasions like Ram Naumi. And when this constituency being very close to Nepal hundreds of Mosques & Madarsas have come up, cow slaughter have been a common site there. Hindus have started living in fear there, so any comments which Varun has made if gave a confidence to the hindus there should have been welcomed. And I consider Mr. Varun Gandhi is a intelligent guy since he has not pointed out any community in his speech. Instead of reporting the problems that hindu community is facing there, the media is busy and happy making a mockery of it. A surprise also came from the BJP since they have cornered from the comments made by the young leader.
Post a Comment